Medication Management in Columbus: When a Refill Isn't Enough
By Lance Demaline • September 21, 2026
Quick Answer: Medication management is ongoing psychiatric care for your medication: an evaluation, a treatment plan, regular follow-up, and adjustments based on how you're actually doing. It's different from getting a prescription refilled. If you're on an antidepressant that isn't working well, or you've lost your prescriber and your primary care doctor is keeping you going on repeat prescriptions, it's usually the step that's missing. Optimum TMS offers focused medication management in Columbus for adults whose main concern is depression or OCD.
A lot of people on antidepressants aren't really being treated. They're being maintained. The prescription gets renewed, the dose hasn't changed in years, and nobody has asked whether it's still working because the appointment is ten minutes long and mostly about the refill. That's not a criticism of primary care, which carries a huge amount of mental health prescribing and does it well for many people. It's a description of what happens when a routine refill is doing the job that ongoing psychiatric care should be doing.
What a refill does, and what it doesn't
A refill keeps you on what you're already taking. That's valuable if the medication is working. It isn't designed to answer the questions that matter when it isn't:
- Is this the right medication for what I actually have?
- Is the dose right, or has it been sitting at a starting dose for years?
- Are the side effects worth what I'm getting from it?
- Is it time to try something different, add something, or stop something?
- Would a treatment other than medication help more?
Medication management is built around those questions. The appointment is about how you're doing, measured properly, and the prescription follows from that rather than the other way round.
Signs you need more than a refill
Any of these is a reasonable prompt to ask for a proper medication review:
- You're better, but not well. Your worst symptoms lifted and you've been at "okay-ish" for a long time. Partial response is easy to live with for years without anyone calling it a problem.
- It used to work and doesn't now. A medication that helped for a stretch has faded, and no one has revisited it.
- Side effects are costing you. Weight gain, sexual side effects, emotional blunting, fatigue. These are worth raising, not tolerating quietly.
- Nobody has changed anything in years. If your prescription looks the same as it did several years ago and you're not fully well, that's worth a second look.
- You've lost your prescriber. They retired, moved, left your network, or your psychiatrist's waitlist is months long.
- You've tried several medications. At that point the question is no longer which pill to try next, and a psychiatric specialist can tell you whether other treatments are worth considering.
What medication management actually involves
An initial evaluation. A full psychiatric history, your past medications and how each one went, other health conditions, sleep, substance use, and a safety assessment. This is also where the diagnosis gets checked. Depression that hasn't responded to treatment sometimes turns out to be depression plus something else, or something else entirely, and that changes what's likely to help.
A plan. That might mean adjusting your dose, switching, adding something, or tapering something that isn't earning its place. It includes an honest conversation about side effects and how long before you'd expect to know if a change is working.
Measured follow-up. Standardized rating scales at your visits, so progress is tracked rather than guessed at. Depression is a poor judge of its own severity, and "how are you feeling?" on a bad morning isn't a reliable answer.
Coordination. If you have a therapist or primary care provider, they stay involved. Medication works better alongside therapy for many people, and we'll recommend and coordinate with a therapist when that's part of what you need.
A path onward if medication isn't enough. Because medication management sits inside a clinic that also offers TMS and Spravato, there's somewhere to go if the review shows medication alone isn't getting you where you need to be. You don't have to start again with a new provider to have that conversation.
Medication management at Optimum TMS is provided by Kayla Cartwright, PMHNP-BC, a board-certified psychiatric nurse practitioner, under the medical direction of Dr. Mark E. Blair, MD, a board-certified psychiatrist.
Still weighing your options?
A quick consultation answers more than another hour of reading.

Who our program is for
Our medication management program is designed for adults who:
- Have depression or OCD as their main concern
- Don't currently have a prescribing provider
- May also have anxiety or PTSD symptoms alongside the depression or OCD
- Are appropriate for outpatient care
Who it isn't for
This is a focused program, not a general psychiatry clinic, and it's better to know that before you book than after your first visit. It is not designed for:
- ADHD evaluation, stimulant medication, or ongoing ADHD medication management
- Bipolar disorder or psychosis
- Active substance use treatment
- Emergency psychiatric care
- Complex medication regimens outside our defined scope
We also don't start benzodiazepines for routine daily or long-term treatment of anxiety, insomnia, or stress. If you already take one, that can be reviewed case by case, but continuing it isn't guaranteed.
If your needs fall outside this, we'll tell you at the screening stage and point you toward a provider who's a better fit.
Already have a psychiatrist?
Then you probably don't need our medication management program, and we wouldn't try to move you. If your current treatment isn't working, you can still see us for a TMS or Spravato consultation while your existing prescriber carries on managing your medication.
Can my primary care doctor keep prescribing instead?
For many people, yes, especially when a medication is working well. Medication management makes the most sense when it isn't working, when the picture is complicated, or when you've tried several options without success.
Do I need a referral?
No referral is needed. If you'd like your therapist or primary care provider involved, we'll coordinate with them.
Is medication management covered by insurance?
It's billed as specialist psychiatric care, and we'll verify your benefits before your first appointment so you know what to expect.
How often are follow-up appointments?
More often at the start or after a medication change, less often once you're stable. Your prescriber will set the interval with you.
What if medication still doesn't help?
That's where the rest of the clinic comes in. Depression that hasn't responded to several medication trials may qualify for TMS or Spravato, both typically covered by insurance when criteria are met.
What if I'm in crisis?
Call or text 988, or go to your nearest emergency department. Our program isn't set up for emergency care.






















